So far we’ve looked at villains who were ruled by a single motivator in the negative. But what happens when a villain is balanced and chooses to use that balance destructively? Syndrome from The Incredibles embodies this idea perfectly.
What Does Syndrome Want?
In the beginning of the story Buddy Pine calls himself Incrediboy, the self-proclaimed sidekick and biggest fan of Mr. Incredible. He has no superpowers. Just a genius mind and desperation to stand beside his hero.
When Mr. Incredible turns him away and gives him over to authorities because he’s caused more harm than good, Buddy internalizes the rejection. Admiration becomes resentment and Incrediboy becomes Syndrome. From that moment his goal shifts: if the world will not accept him as a hero, then the world will have no heroes. This belief is captured in his famous line: “And when everyone’s super, no one will be.”
Balanced in the Negative
To be a balanced character means to act in all four motivators. That’s why we’ve saved Syndrome for last. He does not fall into the trap of a single motivator’s negative conflict strategies. Instead, he draws from all four.
Stabilizer
When Incrediboy was rejected, his strong sense of justice was corrupted. Instead of upholding what was right, he made a decision: if heroes would not accept him, then there would be no heroes at all. He chose to level the playing field for all.
Driver
He’s relentless in his pursuit of progress. He has set his goal, and nothing can stop him. His inventions move forward at any cost, crushing whatever stands in his way.
Solutionary
This is where his genius mind shows itself. As a child he built rocket boots. As an adult he created omnidroids, machines designed to adapt and learn from their opponents. Instead of solving problems for the good of others, he creates problems to serve his own agenda.
Influencer
At his core, Buddy wants recognition. As a boy he longed to stand beside his hero, to be seen and valued. As Syndrome, that need for recognition takes the form of showmanship. He parades his inventions, stages his heroics, and persuades in a way that only an Influencer could.
What Writers Can Learn
Every villain we’ve talked about is strong in one motivator that’s taken to the extreme. Syndrome on the other hand is dangerous because he uses all four. It makes him unpredictable, adaptable, and very hard to defeat.
Writers can learn from Syndrome that balance is not automatically good. In the hands of a hero, balance can create wisdom, adaptability, charisma, and strong leadership. In the hands of a villain it’s decisive and pointed chaos.
This brings us to the larger lesson of our Motivated Villains series. Dolores Umbridge showed us how a Stabilizer in the negative clings to order and justice until it crushes others. Azula revealed the relentlessness of a Driver who will not stop until progress is achieved, no matter the cost. Jareth embodied the Solutionary’s tendency to deconstruct until nothing stable is left. Hans demonstrated the charm of an Influencer gone wrong. And now Syndrome closes the circle, showing us what happens when balance itself is corrupted.
The best villains are not defined only by their goals, but by the motivators that fuel them. By understanding how each motivator can twist in the negative, writers can create villains who last. Villains who challenge heroes on the deepest level, and stay with readers long after the story ends.
If you’re looking for more practical tools to build compelling characters, be sure to join the newsletter. As a bonus, you’ll get a free short story set in a fantasy world, exclusively available only to subscribers.
📩 [Subscribe Here]
If you want to understand what motivates your characters—and yourself—start by taking the free Human NEXUS profile test:
🔗 Learn Your Profile
💬 Use code ROlson10off for a discount on the full version
Find us on these platforms
🌍 Website: RebekahOlsonVentures.com
📘 Facebook: AuthorRebekahOlson
🐦 X (Twitter): @Author_R_Olson
🕊 Truth Social:@RebekahOlson